ST. LOUIS — A judge on Thursday sentenced a woman to 13 years for manslaughter after she tracked her stolen car to a gas station, where two men then died in a shootout.
The sentencing came after a jury in March convicted Demesha Coleman of first-degree involuntary manslaughter and armed criminal action in the shooting death of Darius Jackson, 19, who was in her stolen car.
Circuit Judge Madeline Connolly on Thursday said the jury spent hours deliberating their verdict and sentencing recommendation, which was why she stuck with what the jury recommended: nine years for the manslaughter charge and four years for armed criminal action.
“I’m not going to take that away from them,” Connolly said.
By law, Connolly could have sentenced Coleman to less time but not more.
The jury acquitted Coleman in the shooting death of Joseph Farrar, 49, an innocent bystander at the gas station. It also found her not guilty on six counts that included first-degree murder, first-degree assault, armed criminal action and unlawful use of a weapon.
People are also reading…

Coleman
Coleman’s defense attorney, Isaac Dodd, argued on Thursday that several recent first-degree manslaughter convictions resulted in lesser sentences for defendants who had a criminal record. Coleman has no criminal history.
“While we respect the jury’s verdict in this case, we believe the recommendation was after a long and emotional week,” he said in court.
After the sentencing, Dodd said Coleman was in good spirts.
“At least we got a resolution that gets her a lot of life left to live,” he said.
The case’s special prosecutor, Terrence O’Toole Jr., told the Post-Dispatch he was glad the judge stuck with the jury’s recommendation.
“This is what happens when people take the law into their own hands,” he said.
The shooting happened the night of Dec. 21, 2022, after Coleman’s grey Hyundai Tucson was stolen from her driveway.

"I am very happy the judge did not change their decision," said Donna Conner, left, the older sister of Joseph Farrar, who speaks with special prosecutor Terry O'Toole, Jr. after Judge Madeline O. Connolly sentenced Demesha Coleman to thirteen years in prison on Thursday, May 1, 2025, in the 22nd Circuit Court in ӣƵ. Connolly followed the recommendation of the jury who in March, found Coleman guilty of first-degree involuntary manslaughter and armed criminal action in the shooting death of Darius Jackson, 19. Coleman, was not convicted in the shooting death of Joseph Farrar, 49, an innocent bystander.
Coleman’s car was one of 1,621 stolen Kias and Hyundais that year in ӣƵ County during the peak of astronomically high theft rates of those cars. A viral TikTok video showed how to break into and drive off in many models of the South Korean-made vehicles, using just a screwdriver and a USB charging cable.
Coleman called police but when officers didn’t respond fast enough, she decided to follow the car, which had a GPS tracker. Coleman and her 19-year-old son caught up to the car at the Speedie Gas station — now VP Racing Fuels — near North Broadway Street and Riverview Boulevard in the city’s Baden neighborhood.
She and a third man ran up to both sides of the stolen car, which had been parked by the store’s front door, with guns drawn and pointed.
“Get out of my car!” Coleman yelled, she testified in court in March.
A split second later, gunfire and chaos erupted.
Farrar and Jackson both died at the scene. Corion Murphy, 16, was in the stolen car when the gunfire erupted. He was shot in the head but survived.
Coleman and her accomplices left the scene, but she came back alone shortly after and waited for police. She has been in custody since.

Joseph "Joey" Farrar, 49, in an undated family photo. Farrar was shot and killed at a north city gas station in 2022.
Coleman’s son was listed as a defendant with his mom in a grand jury indictment filed in August, but he does not appear to be charged separately in court filings. Police still haven’t found him and during the trial Coleman said she did not know where he was.
The third man who helped Coleman has never been identified beyond the nickname “JJ.”

Demesha Coleman reacts after Judge Madeline O. Connolly sentenced her to thirteen years in prison on Thursday, May 1, 2025, in the 22nd Circuit Court in ӣƵ. Connolly followed the recommendation of the jury, who in March found Coleman guilty of first-degree involuntary manslaughter and armed criminal action in the shooting death of Darius Jackson, 19, who was in the passenger seat of Coleman's stolen SUV, when Coleman tracked it down at a gas station, and exchanged gun fire with the thieves.

Demesha Coleman walks across the courtroom Judge Madeline O. Connolly sentenced her to thirteen years in prison on Thursday, May 1, 2025, in the 22nd Circuit Court in ӣƵ. Connolly followed the recommendation of the jury, who in March found Coleman guilty of first-degree involuntary manslaughter and armed criminal action in the shooting death of Darius Jackson, 19,who was in the passenger seat of Coleman's stolen SUV, when Coleman tracked it down at a gas station, and exchanged gun fire with the thieves.

Judge Madeline O. Connolly sentences Demesha Coleman to thirteen years in prison on Thursday, May 1, 2025, in the 22nd Circuit Court in ӣƵ. Connolly followed the recommendation of a jury, who in March, found Coleman guilty of first-degree involuntary manslaughter and armed criminal action in the shooting death of Darius Jackson, 19, who was in the passenger seat of Coleman's stolen SUV, when Coleman tracked it down at a gas station, and exchanged gun fire with the thieves.
ӣƵ consistently lands on lists of most dangerous cities, but readers need to carefully look at how such lists are prepared.