DENVER — With only a few minutes to talk before bolting to catch the team bus late Monday night, Willson Contreras breezed through a comment on the power jolt his homer gave an idling offense. He paused instead to eagerly make the case for young starter Michael McGreevy to remain in the majors.
“I think he’s ready to stay here,” Contreras said. “Straight up.”
“I agree,” catcher Pedro Pages added from nearby.
After months of McGreevy yo-yoing between levels as an understudy called upon when the Cardinals needed a sixth starter or to cover a doubleheader, the lobbying for him to unpack and stick around started before he took the mound Monday at Coors Field. Manager Oliver Marmol expressed “hope” that McGreevy would remain in the majors and not head to Class AAA Memphis this time on the first available flight.
People are also reading…
And then the right-hander went out and showed why with a season-high seven innings in a 6-2 victory against Colorado. The Cardinals overcame a two-run deficit, and while Contreras collected a home and two RBIs, McGreevy got his best results by retiring 11 consecutive Rockies to coincide with the Cardinals’ rally.
“He doesn’t need to go back to Triple-A,” Contreras continued. “That’s my take, and I’m going to say it. He’s ready. He’s already shown a couple of times and every time he comes here he’s coming to pitch. And he pitches well. If it was my decision, I’d keep him here.
“He had a really good tempo,” the former catcher added. “He had really good body language, a really good attitude. He’s willing to listen, willing to learn, and always asking questions. He has everybody’s back.”
Contreras then brushed his fingers over his left forearm.
“I’m getting chills because every time he’s here, he’s a good energy to have around.”
To make room on the active roster for McGreevy on Monday, the Cardinals optioned Gordon Graceffo to Triple-A Memphis. That’s how it’s gone all summer for a handful of right-handed pitchers. The Cardinals call for them. The Cardinals use them for multiple innings. The Cardinals return them to Memphis and swap out for a fresh arm. Rinse. Repeat. They even call it the “churn.” As a starter, McGreevy is more vulnerable to it because he’s expected to throw multiple innings – and then not again for five or six days. Him staying in the majors after a start would leave the staff short.
But as the season reached Game No. 101 on Monday night, the equation is starting to change and the interest increases to keep McGreevy on staff, possibly in the rotation.
The Cardinals are exploring the marketplace to see if there are teams interested in starter Erick Fedde. Part of the motivation for that move ahead of the July 31 trade deadline is to clear a spot in the rotation for McGreevy. On Monday, Marmol and members of his staff met to discuss adjusting starter Andre Pallante’s schedule as his workload nears a career high. Pallante is set to start Wednesday against the Rockies. McGreevy could stay on turn for this weekend against San Diego at home and allow for the Cardinals to flex or extend Pallante’s between-start rest as they did for lefty Matthew Liberatore.
They want to be open to McGreevy not giving up his grip on starts.
“I hope it’s not a spot start,” Marmol said in his office a few hours before McGreevy’s first pitch. “My hope is that he can stay with us. I hope it works out like that. I think there’s a lot of value in this next stretch for several reasons for him to get a taste of being around Dusty (Blake) and the pitching staff and game-planning and big-league hitters and getting a taste for the ins and outs of that on a consistent basis.”
Beyond the obvious benefits of being around the clubhouse, the service time, and the major-league salary, there is also the message: He’s earned it.
The Cardinals have been candid with McGreevy since spring training about how he pitched well enough to open in the big-league rotation, but the team was so concerned about its pitching depth that strategically, the team argued, it would be best to use him in a recurring role. At this spot in his career he could move easily between levels and the Cardinals bet with his disposition the former first-round pick could handle oscillating between the Cardinals and Redbirds.
There was, however, an added degree of difficulty with the role.
His first big-league start of this season came against the billion-dollar Mets. His second start, a month later, was against the defending World Series champions, the Los Angeles Dodgers. His fourth – 16 days later – was against the division-leading Cubs. And then, coming out of the break, the Cardinals dialed up their minuteman starter and brought him to the majors again.
And it’s Coors.
Time to learn on the job how that sinker works at elevation.
“You’ve always got to view every opportunity as a test,” McGreevy said. “It’s a great opportunity to get better each time out, a great time to prove you’re a big-league pitcher.”
“We wouldn’t do it if we didn’t think he was mentally tough enough to handle it,” Marmol explained. “Or we felt like if it didn’t go well he would be set back by it. He has a strong mentality. The demeanor – I mean it every time and I lead with that because I know that is what is going to continue to allow him to be good. He is stubborn about just doing what it is that gives him success.”
McGreevy (2-1) gave them plenty of examples Monday.
The Rockies got a base hit to lead off the first three innings against McGreevy. Colorado ran itself out of one rally with two outs on the bases, including one at home plate when the runner tried to advance on a grounder to shortstop. They gave McGreevy a gift in the first inning with a bunt. He then got two groundouts. In the third inning, the Rockies capitalized on an error in center field, two bloop singles, and a groundball single for a 2-0 lead. McGreevy leaned into his sinker with runners on to get a hotshot grounder that Masyn Winn spun into a double play.
A few feet in any other direction and the inning kept going, and if it did McGreevy would have stayed with the same stuff until the ball found a fielder.
“It’s all the many pitches I’ve thrown in my life and just trying to trust what I feel as a pitcher,” McGreevy said. “You’re never going to be 100% with what the ball is going to do here. There were some sinkers I threw that cut. Just throw it. Pick a spot and just rip it.”
The double play started McGreevy’s run of 11 consecutive Rockies retired.
During that stretch of four innings, the Cardinals scored in every inning to overtake the Rockies and widen their lead to four runs. And McGreevy started to get a feel for pitching at Coors. The former first-round pick builds his game on sinker command and grounders. He plays a slider off that pitch. Both pitches behaved differently a mile above sea above, and McGreevy had to adjust.
When a single snapped his streak of outs, McGreevy used his curveball more often to finish the seventh inning and pass the game and the lead to the bullpen.
The Rockies did not put any of McGreevy’s 11 curveballs in play.
“The game gives and takes,” he said. “The cutter and curveball were really essential.”
McGreevy, 25, comes straight out of Cardinals central casting – a right-hander from a strong college program who has a sinker and feel for other pitches that allow him to pitch to contact. He got one strikeout in his seven innings Monday. But he also didn’t walk anyone and scattered seven hits – all of them singles. Nine of his 21 outs came on the ground, and at least one used the dimensions of Coors Field to its benefit for a fly out. But he’s not reliant on one pitch to chase meek grounders and that gives him a different look than other contact pitchers.
The Rockies saw six distinct pitches from McGreevy, five of them at least 10 times.
Late Monday night, McGreevy had yet to hear if he should pack up for a flight or, more likely this time, keep ready for a longer spell in the majors.
He made his case.
The manager welcomed it.
Several teammates championed it.
“Whatever happens happens,” McGreevy said. “I understand how this business works. I’m always stoked beyond my mind to get a chance to pitch in the big leagues, and if I stay here for the rest of the year, great. If I go down tomorrow, oh well. You have to smile through it all.”
Post-Dispatch baseball writer Derrick Goold joined columnist Jeff Gordon to discuss which way John Mozeliak might play the deadline.